Skip to content
Our stores are busy! Skip the wait and schedule an appointment HERE.
Chalmers Jewelers
Shopping Cart 0
Close Back
  • Custom Jewelry
    • Our Process
    • Ethically Sourcing
    • Garrett Scott Collection
    • Mokume by Kaleb
    • Past Projects
  • Engagement Rings
    • FANA
    • SYLVIE
    • Garrett Scott Designs
    • Propose Tonight!
    • Design Your Own
    • Photo Gallery
  • Wedding Bands / Stackables
  • Men's Wedding Bands
    • Mokume by Kaleb
    • Benchmark
    • Madani
    • Lashbrook
    • Thorsten
  • Diamond Jewelry
    • Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Necklaces
    • Rings
  • Gemstone Jewelry & Loose Gems
    • Amethyst
    • Blue Topaz
    • Emerald
    • Garnet
    • Opal
    • Pearl
    • Peridot
    • Ruby
    • Sapphire
    • Tanzanite
    • Tourmaline
    • All Rings
    • All Earrings
    • All Necklaces
    • Loose Gemstones
  • Silver & Gold Jewelry
    • Gold Fashion
    • Silver Fashion
  • Watches & Accessories
    • Graham
    • Ball
    • Raymond Weil
    • Montblanc
      • Timepieces
      • Writing Instruments
    • Pre-owned & Vintage
    • Deakin & Francis
  • Exclusive Designers
    • Bassali
    • Fana
    • Frederic Duclos
    • John Hardy
    • Kwiat
    • Luvente
    • Sylvie
  • University of Wisconsin
  • Financing
    • Current Promotions
    • About our AGS Credit Card
  • Reviews
  • Gift Ideas
    • Couture Gifts
    • Gifts over $10,000
    • Gifts Under $1000
    • Gifts Under $500
  • About us
  • Services
  • Contact Us
  • Login
Close
Your cart is currently empty.
0

Total: $0.00

Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout
View Cart
  •  
Continue browsing
Close
Home/Collections/Propose Tonight!

Propose Tonight!

Propose Tonight!
0.40ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.40ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,099.00
Sold Out
2.12ctw Marquise Natural Diamond Custom Engagement Ring
2.12ctw Marquise Natural Diamond Custom Engagement Ring
$17,699.00
1.43ctw 3 Stone Princess Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
1.43ctw 3 Stone Princess Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,126.00
5.46ctw Radiant Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
5.46ctw Radiant Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$44,999.00
1.11ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
1.11ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,399.00
Sold Out
0.93ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.93ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$5,399.00
Sold Out
1.41ctw FOREVERMARK Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
1.41ctw FOREVERMARK Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,495.00
0.69ctw FOREVERMARK Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.69ctw FOREVERMARK Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,999.00
Sold Out
0.99ctw Princess Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.99ctw Princess Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,499.00
Sold Out
0.39ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.39ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$1,499.00
Sold Out
0.58ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.58ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$1,799.00
Sold Out
1.19ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
1.19ctw Round Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,399.00
Sold Out
1.23ctw Pear 3 Stone Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
1.23ctw Pear 3 Stone Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$6,599.00
Sold Out
2.12ctw FOREVERMARK / Douglas Elliot Diamond Engagement Ring
2.12ctw FOREVERMARK / Douglas Elliot Diamond Engagement Ring
$19,299.00
0.74ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.74ctw Oval Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,499.00
Sold Out
0.66ctw Round Halo Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.66ctw Round Halo Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,699.00
Sold Out
0.68ctw Cushion Halo Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
0.68ctw Cushion Halo Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,599.00
Sold Out

Accredited Gem Lab ®

We have the equipment required to perform gemological testing and appraisals set forth by the American Gem Society.

Conflict Free

We only purchase diamonds through the most respected suppliers who, like us, proudly adhere to and enforce the standards established by the Kimberley Process. 

Recycled Materials

Our fine gold and silver has been certified as being from 100% recycled sources by SCS Global - a third-party certification, verification and validation service.

Join Our Sparkle Squad

Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.

Store Hours

MIDDLETON: 

Monday - Friday : 10:00am-6:00pm

Saturday: 10:00am-5:00pm

Sunday: CLOSED

MADISON:

Monday - Friday: 11:00am-6:00pm

Saturday: 10:00am-5:00pm

Sunday: CLOSED

CUSTOMER CARE

Contact Us Locations Store Hours Schedule an Appointment Terms of Service Refund policy

WHY CHALMERS

About Us Warranty Services Financing Career Opportunities Privacy Policy

Follow us

FacebookInstagramYouTubePinterestTikTokEmailPhone

EDUCATION

American Gem Society Blog Buying Guide: Gemstones Buying Guide: Diamonds
Country/region
American Express Apple Pay Diners ClubDiscoverGoogle Pay MastercardShop Pay Visa
Copyright © 2026 Chalmers Jewelers. Powered by Shopify
CELEBRATING THE HAPPIEST MOMENTS IN OUR CUSTOMERS' LIVES SINCE 1992.

Walk-in traffic is welcome, in-store appointments are appreciated. 

Schedule one now!

For updates, offers, and invitations to special events, add your email below.

Read our privacy policy.

Cookies
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on your device.